Photography and Imagery · Step 1 · 5 min read
The photos nobody looks at
Eye-tracking shows that people skip generic, feel-good photos and study the ones that carry information. How to tell decoration from content, the one-question test, and what to do when a screen 'needs a photo'.
People are very good at ignoring photos that don't help them. Eye-tracking keeps showing the same thing: generic, feel-good images get skipped, and images that carry information get studied. Your users have seen the handshake, the laptop on a wooden desk and the team high-fiving in front of a whiteboard. Their eyes go straight past.
What you'll be able to do after reading:
- Tell a decorative photo from a content photo in seconds
- Use one question to decide whether a photo stays
- Recognise the "stock photo look" and know why it fails
- Replace a decorative photo with something useful, or with nothing
1. What eye-tracking found
Nielsen Norman Group has tracked where people look on web pages for years. The pattern in their article on photos is clear (NN/g, Nielsen, Photos as Web Content, 2010):
- Decorative, generic photos are ignored. A stock shot of a smiling group, placed to make a page "friendly", got no fixations at all.
- Photos of real people are studied. On a staff page, people spent about 10% more time on the portraits than on the written bios, even though the bios took up 316% more space.
- Product photos that help people compare are studied. When the photo shows the difference between two items, it's doing the work of a paragraph.
The book behind this research, Eyetracking Web Usability (Nielsen and Pernice, 2010), has many more examples. They all point the same way: attention goes to information.
2. Same product, two jobs
Mood: it sets a feeling
Content: it answers a question
Both photos show headphones. Only one helps someone who wants to buy them. The first is a mood shot: dark, beautiful, mostly shadow. You can't see the cushions, the size, or how the headband sits. The second is less pretty, and it answers the questions a buyer has: how thick the cushions are, how big the ear cups are, what the headband looks like.
That doesn't make the first photo bad. It could be the right image for a brand campaign, a playlist cover or an onboarding screen whose job is to set a feeling. It's the wrong image for a product page, because there the job is to show the thing.
3. The one-question test
If you removed this image, would anyone lose information they need?
- Yes: it's content. Keep it, and make it good (the next steps of this course are about that).
- No: it's decoration. That's allowed, but now it has to earn its place: it must set a mood you can name, be small enough not to push the task away, and be good enough not to look like every other site.
Most decorative photos fail the second part. They're there because the layout had a box, and the box needed filling.
4. The "stock photo look"
You know it when you see it:
- People smiling at nothing, or at a laptop, or at each other in a meeting that never happened.
- The handshake. The lightbulb. The person pointing at a chart.
- Perfect light, perfect teeth, no mess, no context.
The problem isn't that these photos come from a stock library. Good stock photos exist, and you'll learn to choose them in Step 3. The problem is that they're generic: they could sit on any site, so they say nothing about yours. People have learnt that, and they skip them, like they skip banner ads.
5. When the screen "needs a photo"
Sometimes the request is simply "this page looks empty, add a photo". Before you search a stock library, try these, in order:
- Show the real thing. A screenshot of the feature, the product from the angle people ask about, the actual team.
- Show how. A small image that explains the step people get wrong.
- Use the space for the task. Bigger text, a clearer action, a short list of what's included.
- Use nothing. White space is not a bug. The GOV.UK Design System puts it simply: use images only when users need them (GOV.UK Design System, Images).
Only then, if the screen really needs a feeling, choose a decorative image on purpose, and make it a specific one.
6. Common mistakes
- Filling every empty box with a photo.
- Using a stock face on a page where real people exist.
- Judging an image by how it looks alone, not by what it does on that screen.
- Keeping a decorative photo because "the stakeholder likes it", without asking what it should do.
7. Vocabulary
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Fixation | A moment when the eye stops on something; eye-tracking counts them |
| Eye-tracking | Research that records where people look on a screen, and for how long |
| Stock photo | A photo licensed from a library, made to fit many uses |
| Mood shot | A photo whose job is to create a feeling, not to inform |
8. Try it (no tools needed)
- Open three websites in the same category (three banks, three gyms, three airlines).
- Screenshot the first screen of each.
- For every photo, apply the one-question test. Count the content photos and the decorative ones.
- Swap the decorative photos between the three sites in your head. Do they still fit? If they do, they were generic.
Reflection questions: Which of the three sites used an image you'd actually miss? What made it specific?
9. If you already practise
- Run the one-question test in design reviews, out loud. It's quick and it doesn't sound like personal taste.
- Keep a swipe file of specific images from products you admire, with a note on the job each one does. It's more useful than a mood board of pretty photos.
- When you must use a decorative image, crop it tight and keep it small. A specific detail reads as intention; a wide generic scene reads as filler.
Checklist
Learn more
- NN/g: Photos as Web Content (Nielsen, 2010) · Image-Focused Design: Is Bigger Better? (Whitenton, 2014)
- GOV.UK Design System: Images
Books, courses and videos to go deeper
Book links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Related
What an image does in a product · Photo, illustration or nothing · Audit the images in your product