Marcus Andrey Study
Ler em português Library

Framework · Imagery · 3 min read

Composition guides

Four guides for reading and choosing a photo for a screen (thirds, leading lines, visual weight and negative space), used as reasons a photo works, not as rules it must pass.

1Thirds

Subject near a third line, the rest of the frame left free.

A start, not a test
2Lines

Roads, rails and edges that lead the eye to the subject.

Or out of the frame
3Weight

Size, contrast and colour decide what pulls the eye.

Watch the edges
4Space

The calm area where a headline fits without covering the subject.

Room for words

One subject first, then the four guides as reasons

Four composition guides explain why a photo works on a screen, and where its text can go.

Use it when

  • You choose a hero or card image and need to say why one photo works better than another.
  • A critique stalls on "I don't like it" and you need words a stakeholder can follow.
  • You write an image brief and want photos that arrive with room for a headline.

How to use it

  1. Name the subject in two words. "The bread", "her hands". If you can't, the photo has no subject yet, and no guide will rescue it. Output: the subject, written down.
  2. Check where it sits. On a third line or where two cross, the rest of the frame stays free; dead centre with equal halves reads as symmetry, still and formal. Both are choices. Output: centre, third or edge, and why.
  3. Follow the lines. Roads, rails, fences, a row of windows: see whether they lead to the subject or out of the frame. Output: what leads the eye, and where to.
  4. Weigh the frame. Size, contrast and colour give an area weight. A small bright spot at the edge can outweigh a large calm one in the middle. Output: the heaviest area, and anything at the edges that pulls the eye away.
  5. Find the negative space. Mark the calm area where a headline, a button or a caption can sit without covering the subject. Output: the side or band for text, or "none, choose another photo".

Worked example

The bakery ordering app needs a photo for the sourdough's product card and has three candidates. Photo A centres the loaf on a busy counter: strong subject, no calm area. Photo B puts the loaf on the right third, with a plain wall on the left: the lines of the table lead to it, and the wall is room for the name and price. Photo C is beautiful but a bright red tin at the edge outweighs the bread. The team picks B and writes "subject on a third, calm space on the left for the name" into the brief for the next shoot.

Guide Photo A Photo B Photo C
Subject Loaf, centred Loaf, right third Loaf, left third
Leading lines None Table edge, to the loaf Counter, out of frame
Visual weight Clutter around it On the loaf Red tin at the edge
Negative space None Plain wall, left Top band, busy

Watch out for

  • Thirds as a quality test. In 2014, Amirshahi and colleagues found that following the rule of thirds had at most a minor role in how beautiful people found photos. Use it to explain, not to judge.
  • No room for the text. A great photo with no calm area ends with text on the subject, and a fight for contrast later.
  • Ignoring the edges. A bright object or half a person at the border pulls the eye out of the frame.
  • Guides instead of a subject. Lines and thirds can't fix a photo that isn't about one thing.

Template

Copy this into an image review or a brief, one block per photo.

Photo: ...
Subject (two words): ...
Where it sits: centre / third / edge, because ...
What leads to it: ...
Heaviest area: ...   Distractions at the edges: ...
Negative space for text: ... (side or band), or none
Verdict: use / use with a crop (...) / don't use, because ...
Source
The term "rule of thirds": John Thomas Smith, Remarks on Rural Scenery (1797). The guides as a way of looking: Michael Freeman, The Photographer's Eye (2007, remastered 2017). Evidence on thirds and beauty: Seyed Ali Amirshahi and colleagues (Art & Perception, 2014)
Where to find it
Photography and Imagery in UX: Composition › Four tools, not four rules

"See on Amazon" links are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Saved only on this device.

↑ ↓ to move · Enter to open · Esc to close