Marcus Andrey Study
Ler em português Library

Framework · Imagery · 3 min read

Image role check

Four questions to ask of any image slot before you look for a picture: what job it does, which promise it makes (photo, illustration or nothing), how big the job is, and what the alt text says, so every image on a screen has a reason to be there.

1Job

Show the thing, show how, show who, orient or set the mood.

"It fills the space" is not a job
2Promise

Photo: this is real. Illustration: an idea. Nothing: the task first.

No job usually means nothing
3Size

Visual weight in the order of the page's goals.

Cover it: is the action easier?
4Alt text

The job, written down. Decoration gets an empty alt.

alt="" for mood only

Job → promise → size → alt text, before anyone looks for a picture

Four questions for every image slot: the job comes first, and the picture comes last.

Use it when

  • A layout has an empty box marked "image here" and nobody can say what goes in it.
  • Someone asks for "a nice photo" for a form, a settings page or a checkout.
  • You audit a product and want one short reason for every image you keep, and a reason for every one you cut.

How to use it

  1. Name the job. Pick one of the five: show the thing, show how, show who, orient, set the mood. "It fills the space" is not a job. Output: one sentence, "This image is here to … for … so they can …".
  2. Choose the promise. A photo when the real thing matters (a product, a person, a place, proof). An illustration when the idea matters (abstract, not built yet, sensitive). Nothing when the task matters. Output: photo, illustration or nothing, with the reason.
  3. Check the source against the promise. A generated image looks like a photo but is not a record of anything, so never use it where people will read it as proof. Output: shoot, library, illustration or generated, and why that is honest here.
  4. Size it to the job. Cover the image with your hand. If the main action gets easier to find, the image is too big for its job. Output: a size and position that never pushes the main task down.
  5. Write the alt text from the job. The job you named in step 1 is most of the alt text. Decoration gets alt="". Output: the alt text, or alt="", written next to the image in the design.

Worked example

A small bakery's ordering app has four image slots in its first design.

Slot Job Promise Decision
Home hero Show that the bread is baked here, every morning Photo: it must be real Keep: own shoot of the real shelves, 4:5 crop on phones, calm top third for the headline
Order form None ("it looks empty") Nothing: the task comes first Cut: the form is the point
"How pick-up works" Show how: where the pick-up shelf is Illustration: a simple sketch of the shop counter Keep, small, next to the step it explains
Empty basket Set the mood Illustration in the app's style Keep, small; alt="" because the text already says the basket is empty

Watch out for

  • "It sets the mood" for every image. Then nothing is content. Say which mood, and why this screen needs it.
  • A face as a trust button. Real people shown for a real reason can make a service feel human. A stock model does not.
  • A photo of something that doesn't exist yet. A mock-up dressed as a photo breaks the promise of reality.
  • Treating "no image" as a gap. On task screens it is the right answer more often than not, and it's the cheapest one to ship.

Template

Copy one block per image slot into the design file or the audit.

Screen: ...
Slot: ...
Job (show the thing / show how / show who / orient / set the mood): ...
  This image is here to ... for ... so they can ...
Promise: photo / illustration / nothing, because ...
Source: own shoot / library / illustration / generated, honest here because ...
Size test (cover it with your hand): the main action is ... easier to find
Alt text: ...   (or alt="")
Decision: keep / change / cut
Source
Image jobs and promises: this course. Use images only when users need them: GOV.UK Design System, Images. Visual weight follows the page's goals: Kathryn Whitenton, Nielsen Norman Group (2014)

"See on Amazon" links are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Saved only on this device.

↑ ↓ to move · Enter to open · Esc to close