Marcus Andrey Study
Ler em português Library

Framework · People leadership · 3 min read

Crucial Conversations

A toolkit for high-stakes, emotional conversations: start with heart, make it safe, then STATE your path so you can say the hard thing and still hear the other side.

  1. SShare facts

    Start with what anyone could observe. Facts are the least controversial part.

    "The last three handoffs were late."
  2. TTell story

    Say what you are starting to conclude, and label it as your view.

    "I'm starting to think the dates feel unrealistic."
  3. AAsk theirs

    Invite their facts and their story before you go further.

    "How do you see it?"
  4. TBe tentative

    Speak as someone who could be wrong, but still say it.

    "I may be missing something."
  5. EInvite testing

    Make it safe to disagree, especially for the quieter person.

    "If my picture is off, tell me."

Before you start: start with heart. If emotions rise: stop and make it safe.

The STATE path from Crucial Conversations: share your view clearly while keeping the other person safe to share theirs.

Use it when

  • You need to tell a designer that their performance is below what the role needs.
  • A product manager and a designer are in open conflict, and both expect you to take their side.
  • You disagree with your own manager on a decision that affects your team.

How to use it

  1. Start with heart. Before the conversation, ask yourself what you really want for you, for them and for the relationship. Also ask what you would do if you really wanted those things. Output: one sentence on what you want, written down.
  2. Watch for the moment it turns crucial. Notice when stakes are high, opinions differ and emotions are strong: raised voices, silence, sarcasm, a sudden "fine". Output: you notice the shift instead of reacting to it.
  3. Make it safe. If they go silent or attack, step out of the content. Restate the shared purpose ("we both want this release to work for operators") and show respect. Apologise if you caused the problem. Output: the other person is willing to keep talking.
  4. STATE your path. Share the facts first, then tell your story (how you read them), then ask for their view. Talk tentatively and invite them to test your story. Output: your view on the table, said as a view, not a verdict.
  5. Agree what happens next. Decide who does what by when, and how you will follow up. Output: a written next step with an owner and a date.

Worked example

A UX lead on an internal operations platform needs to talk to a designer who has missed three handoff dates in a row. The lead feels frustrated and wants a good outcome.

Step What the lead says
Start with heart (to herself) "I want the handoffs to land, and I want her to feel she can tell me when she's stuck."
Share facts "The last three handoffs came two to four days after the date we agreed."
Tell your story "I'm starting to think the dates we set don't feel realistic to you."
Ask for theirs "How do you see it?"
Talk tentatively "I may be wrong. Maybe something else is going on."
Encourage testing "If my picture is off, I really want to know."
Make it safe (when she goes quiet) "I'm not here to blame you. I want us to set dates you can trust."

The designer explains she is pulled into support requests every afternoon. They agree she will log the requests for a week, and the lead will raise them with the product manager.

Watch out for

  • Starting with your story. "You don't care about deadlines" is a conclusion. Start with the facts both of you can see.
  • Silence or violence. People either shut down or push harder when they feel unsafe. Both signal that you need to restore safety, not add more arguments.
  • Talking tentatively until the message disappears. Tentative means open to being wrong, not vague. Still say the hard part clearly.
  • No follow-up. A good conversation without a written next step often changes nothing.

Template

Fill this in before the conversation. Keep it short enough to read in one minute.

Conversation with:              Date:

Start with heart
  What I want for me:
  What I want for them:
  What I want for the relationship:

Shared purpose (to restore safety):

STATE
  Share facts:         (what anyone could observe)
  Tell my story:       (what I'm starting to conclude)
  Ask for theirs:      "How do you see it?"
  Talk tentatively:    "I may be wrong, but..."
  Encourage testing:   "If you see it differently, tell me."

Next step / owner / date:
Source
Patterson, Grenny, McMillan & Switzler

Books to go deeper

"See on Amazon" links are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Saved only on this device.

↑ ↓ to move · Enter to open · Esc to close