Framework · People leadership · 2 min read
Structured hiring interview
Same questions for every candidate, scored on a rubric by more than one interviewer, starting from a written scorecard, so you hire on evidence instead of gut feeling.
- 1Scorecard
Outcomes, competencies and culture contribution, written before reading CVs.
"What must this person achieve?" - 2Same questions
One question set, mapped to the scorecard, for every candidate.
"Tell me about a time you…" - 3Rubric
Describe weak, solid and strong answers before the interviews.
"What does a strong answer include?" - 4Portfolio
Ask about decisions and trade-offs, not only visuals.
"Why this solution, and what did you trade?" - 5Score alone
More than one interviewer scores independently, then they discuss.
"What evidence backs your score?"
Use it when
- You are hiring your first designer as a lead and want a fair, repeatable process.
- Interviewers on your panel disagree, and the loudest opinion tends to win.
- Portfolio reviews keep turning into a judgement of visual style.
How to use it
- Write the scorecard before reading CVs. List the outcomes for the role, the competencies you need and the culture contribution you are looking for. Use your Career ladder for the level. Output: a one-page scorecard.
- Write the same questions for every candidate. Map each question to a scorecard competency. Ask about real past situations: "Tell me about a time you…". Output: a question set, one or two per competency.
- Define the rubric. For each question, describe what a weak, solid and strong answer looks like. Output: a scoring guide every interviewer uses.
- Ask about decisions in the portfolio. Ask why they chose this solution, what they traded off and what they would change. Don't judge only the visuals. Output: evidence of how the candidate thinks.
- Score independently, then discuss. Each interviewer scores and writes notes before the debrief. Then compare scores and the evidence behind them. Output: a decision based on evidence from more than one interviewer.
Worked example
A UX lead on an internal operations platform hires a Senior product designer. Her scorecard has three competencies. For "handles complex data", every candidate gets the same question and the same rubric.
| Part | What the lead wrote |
|---|---|
| Question | "Tell me about a screen with a lot of data where you had to decide what to hide. What did you decide, and why?" |
| Weak | Talks about the visual layout only; no clear reason for the choice. |
| Solid | Explains the users' main task and how it shaped what was visible. |
| Strong | Explains the trade-off, how they tested it with users and what they changed afterwards. |
Two interviewers score alone. One gives "strong", one "solid". In the debrief, they compare evidence and see that the candidate did not mention testing with users, so they agree on "solid".
Watch out for
- Changing the questions per candidate. Different questions make answers impossible to compare. Follow-up questions are fine; the core set stays the same.
- Group discussion before scoring. The first opinion in the room anchors everyone. Collect written scores first.
- "Culture fit" as a gut feeling. It often means "like us". Look for culture contribution, written on the scorecard.
- Visual style only. A beautiful portfolio may hide weak decisions. Ask about the reasoning and the trade-offs.
Template
Fill the scorecard once per role and copy the question block for each competency.
Role: Level:
Outcomes for the first year:
1.
2.
Competencies:
1.
2.
3.
Culture contribution:
Competency:
Question: "Tell me about a time you..."
Weak:
Solid:
Strong:
Interviewer: Score (weak / solid / strong):
Evidence (what they said):