Framework · Measurement · 3 min read
UX maturity model
Nielsen Norman Group's six stages (Absent, Limited, Emergent, Structured, Integrated, User-driven), assessed across four factors, so you can place your organisation and pick the next factor to improve.
-
1 Absent
- Signs
- UX is ignored or doesn't exist
- For example
- Developers design screens as they build
-
2 Limited
- Signs
- Sporadic, unreliable UX that depends on individuals
- For example
- One designer, pulled in late
-
3 Emergent
- Signs
- Functional and promising, but inconsistent and inefficient
- For example
- Good work in some teams, no shared methods
-
4 Structured
- Signs
- Semi-systematic, effectiveness varies across teams
- For example
- Design system and research process, unevenly used
-
5 Integrated
- Signs
- Comprehensive, effective and pervasive
- For example
- UX metrics shape every roadmap
-
6 User-driven
- Signs
- Dedicated UX at all levels drives insight and outcomes
- For example
- User insight steers company strategy
Assess each stage across four factors: strategy, culture, process, outcomes.
Use it when
- You are new in the role and need an evidence-based picture of where UX stands, instead of a gut feeling.
- Your manager asks "How mature is our UX?" and you need a clear, honest answer.
- You are setting yearly goals for the practice and need to choose where to invest first.
How to use it
- Form a hypothesis. In your first weeks, guess a stage per domain from what you see and hear. Write it down as a guess, for example "Emergent to Structured (3–4)". Output: a one-line hypothesis per domain.
- Run the baseline. Ask each designer and one product manager per domain to complete NN/g's free UX maturity quiz. Add 4–5 questions specific to your organisation, such as "Is there a UX request process?" or "Are usage metrics available?". Output: answers per domain. Allow two weeks.
- Score the four factors. For each domain, place strategy (leadership, planning, prioritisation, resourcing), culture (awareness, knowledge, growth of UX), process (methods, research, systematisation) and outcomes (UX goals, measurement, impact on decisions) on a stage. Output: a stage per factor per domain.
- Visualise it as a heatmap. Put domains in rows and factors in columns. Share it with your manager and product managers as a picture of the system, never of individuals. Output: a domain × factor heatmap.
- Choose one or two factors to move. Pick the factors that block the others most, often outcomes or process. Turn them into goals for the year. Output: one or two maturity goals with owners.
- Repeat every 6–12 months. Run the same baseline again and compare. Output: an updated heatmap and a short note on what changed.
Worked example
A fictional internal operations platform with 6 product teams. Before the baseline, the new lead writes down what they observe and places each factor.
| Factor | Signals you observe | Placement |
|---|---|---|
| Strategy | No UX goals in the product roadmap. Designers are funded per project, and each team decides alone whether it needs one. | Limited (2) |
| Culture | Product managers ask for designers early in most teams. Two teams still see UX as "making it look nice". | Emergent (3) |
| Process | A shared design system and component library exist, but research and critique happen in some teams only. | Structured (4) in two teams, Emergent (3) elsewhere |
| Outcomes | Nobody tracks task success or satisfaction. Launches are judged by delivery date. | Limited (2) |
Watch out for
- Averaging into one number. "We are a 3" hides that process is at 4 and outcomes at 2. The gaps tell you where to act.
- Scoring alone. Your own guess is a hypothesis. Without designers and product managers in the baseline, it is just your opinion.
- Trying to jump stages. Moving a whole organisation up one stage usually takes years. Aim for one or two factors per year.
- Turning it into a team ranking. A heatmap that shames one domain stops people answering honestly. Present it as the state of the system.
Template
Copy this into a doc or spreadsheet and fill one row per domain (stages 1–6).
Domain / team | Strategy | Culture | Process | Outcomes | Notes
-------------------|----------|---------|---------|----------|------
| | | | |
| | | | |
| | | | |
Stages: 1 Absent · 2 Limited · 3 Emergent · 4 Structured · 5 Integrated · 6 User-driven
Hypothesis before baseline:
Factors to move this year (max 2):
Next baseline date:
- The User Experience Team of OneLeah Buley (2nd ed. with Joe Natoli)Book · 2013 (Amazon)
- The 6 Levels of UX MaturityNN/g (external site)
- Four Factors in UX MaturityNN/g (external site)
- UX Maturity QuizNN/g (external site)
- Using the UX-Maturity Model Without a Formal AssessmentNN/g (external site)
- The UX Maturity ModelNN/gVideo (external site)
"See on Amazon" links are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Saved only on this device.