Marcus Andrey Study
Ler em português Library

Framework · Motion & interaction · 3 min read

Motion purpose check

Name the one job each animation does (feedback, state change, orientation, relationship or attention), check that it starts fast and only one thing moves at a time, and cut whatever has no job you can name in one word.

FFeedback

"I got your action." Starts within about 0.1 s.

A checkbox fills as you tick
SState change

"This became that."

A menu icon turns into a close icon
OOrientation

"This is where you are, and where this lives."

A panel closes to the edge it came from
RRelationship

"This came from that."

New fields grow out of the option
AAttention

"Look here, something changed." The loudest job: one at a time.

The cart badge bumps once

No job you can name in one word: cut it, or make it an instant change.

The five jobs motion does in an interface; anything that does none of them is a candidate to cut.

Use it when

  • A spec or a prototype arrives full of motion and you need to decide what stays.
  • A review turns into "I like it" against "I don't", and you need a better question.
  • You start an audit of the motion in a product and need one label per animation.

How to use it

  1. List every motion moment. Do the task once and write down everything that moves: what moves, what triggers it, how often people meet it. Output: a list of motion moments, one per line.
  2. Name the job in one word. Feedback ("I got your action"), state change ("this became that"), orientation ("this is where you are"), relationship ("this came from that") or attention ("look here"). Output: one job next to each moment, or a blank.
  3. Cut the blanks. A moment with no job is either decoration or a mistake. Cut it, or replace it with an instant change. A cut is a design too. Output: a shorter list.
  4. Check the timing of cause and effect. Feedback must start within about 0.1 second of the action, or it stops feeling caused by it. Output: every feedback moment marked fast or late.
  5. Check that one thing asks for attention at a time. If two moments fire together and both say "look here", keep the one that matters and quiet the other. Nothing should move at the edge of the screen while people read. Output: one attention moment per change.
  6. Judge the frequent ones the third time. An animation you see fifty times a day must be short or gone. Watch it three times in a row before you keep it. Output: frequent moments shortened or cut.
  7. Write the job into the spec. One word next to each animation. It turns the next review into "does it do its job". Output: a spec where every animation has a job.

Worked example

A task app for small teams goes through its main flow. The team finds six motion moments:

Moment How often Job Decision
The checkbox fills when you tick a task All day Feedback Keep, at about 100 ms
A finished task slides into the "Done" list All day Relationship Keep, shorter
Confetti on every finished task All day None (character) Cut
The logo pulses every 10 seconds Always None Cut
The comments badge bumps once on a new comment A few times a day Attention Keep
The whole page fades when you switch tabs All day None you can name Replace with an instant change

Three of six had no job. The three that stay each tell the person something: the tick was received, the task went to "Done", someone commented.

Watch out for

  • "Delight" as the job. Delight is how a job feels when it's done well. On its own, it's not a job.
  • Attention spent on the wrong thing. The same bump that helps a cart badge becomes a dark pattern on a countdown or a chat pop-up.
  • Feedback that starts late. A press that answers after a beat looks like the system did something on its own.
  • Judging from a review. In a review you watch each animation once. Users meet it a hundred times.

Template

Copy this table into the spec or the audit, one row per motion moment.

Moment                     | Trigger        | How often     | Job (one word) | Starts within 0.1 s? | Decision
---------------------------|----------------|---------------|----------------|----------------------|-------------------
...                        | ...            | ...           | ...            | yes / no             | keep / shorten / cut

Jobs: feedback · state change · orientation · relationship · attention
No job you can name in one word: cut it, or make it an instant change.
Source
The five jobs: Page Laubheimer, The Role of Animation and Motion in UX (NN/g, 2020). The 0.1 second limit for cause and effect: Aurora Harley, Animation for Attention and Comprehension (NN/g, 2014). Expectation, continuity, narrative and relationship: Issara Willenskomer, the UX in Motion manifesto (2017)

"See on Amazon" links are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Saved only on this device.

↑ ↓ to move · Enter to open · Esc to close