Framework · Strategy & vision · 3 min read
Strategy kernel
Richard Rumelt's three-part core of a good strategy (a diagnosis of the critical challenge, a guiding policy, and coherent actions that reinforce each other) that you can use to build a UX strategy instead of a list of goals.
- 1Diagnosis
The critical challenge. Mark each claim as evidence or assumption.
"What's really going on?" - 2Guiding policy
One sentence: the overall approach, and what it rules out.
"What is our approach?" - 3Coherent actions
A few pillars of concrete actions that reinforce each other.
"How does each pillar help another?"
Revisit the diagnosis as evidence replaces assumptions.
Use it when
- Someone asks you for "the UX strategy" and your first draft is a list of goals ("be world-class", "improve consistency").
- You finish a listening tour in your first 30 days and need to turn what you heard into a direction.
- Your team does many good things, but nobody can say what they add up to.
How to use it
- Write the diagnosis. In 3–4 sentences, describe what is really going on: the critical challenge, not every problem. Mark each claim as evidence or assumption. Output: a short diagnosis with labelled claims.
- Write the guiding policy. In one sentence, state the overall approach to deal with the challenge, and what it rules out. Output: one guiding-policy sentence.
- Group your actions into pillars. Take your planned actions and group them into 3–5 themes. Each theme becomes a pillar of coherent actions. Output: 3–5 pillars, each with 2–4 concrete actions.
- Check coherence. For each pillar, name one way it helps another. If a pillar helps nothing else, question it. Output: a short list of "pillar A helps pillar B because…".
- Test it with your manager. Present the kernel, not a slide deck: "Here's the challenge, here's the approach, here are actions that reinforce each other. What am I missing?" Output: feedback and a revised kernel.
Worked example
The four-pillar example from the module. It is one example, not a template to copy: derive your own pillars from your own diagnosis.
Coherent actions (the pillars):
| Pillar | Actions |
|---|---|
| 1. Consistent practice | Shared principles, design-system governance, common process "minimum standard" |
| 2. Growth & learning | Cross-domain critique, mentoring pairs, career ladder, knowledge base |
| 3. Transparent capacity | Intake process, capacity map, prioritisation criteria agreed with stakeholders |
| 4. Evidence-driven UX | Maturity baseline, GDPR-safe metrics, lightweight benchmark of top tasks |
The pillars reinforce each other: shared standards make cross-domain critique possible; capacity transparency frees time for research; evidence feeds the standards.
Watch out for
- Goals posing as strategy. "Be world-class" is a wish, not a strategy. Start from a diagnosis of what is actually in the way.
- A list of everything. If every activity the team does appears, nothing has been chosen. A guiding policy also says what you won't do.
- A confident diagnosis built on guesses. Mark what is evidence and what is assumption. "My hypothesis is X; I'd confirm it by Y" is stronger than a plan built on guesses.
- Copying someone else's pillars. Pillars come from your diagnosis. Another organisation may need three, five or completely different ones.
Template
Copy this into a one-page strategy draft.
Diagnosis (3-4 sentences, the critical challenge):
1. [evidence / assumption]
2. [evidence / assumption]
3. [evidence / assumption]
Guiding policy (one sentence: the approach, and what it rules out):
Coherent actions
Pillar 1: Actions:
Pillar 2: Actions:
Pillar 3: Actions:
Coherence check
Pillar 1 helps Pillar __ because:
Pillar 2 helps Pillar __ because:
Pillar 3 helps Pillar __ because:
- Good Strategy Bad StrategyRichard P. RumeltBook · 2011 (Amazon)
- UX Strategy: Definition and ComponentsNN/g (external site)
"See on Amazon" links are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.