Marcus Andrey Study
Ler em português Library

Framework · Strategy & vision · 3 min read

Strategy kernel

Richard Rumelt's three-part core of a good strategy (a diagnosis of the critical challenge, a guiding policy, and coherent actions that reinforce each other) that you can use to build a UX strategy instead of a list of goals.

  1. 1Diagnosis

    The critical challenge. Mark each claim as evidence or assumption.

    "What's really going on?"
  2. 2Guiding policy

    One sentence: the overall approach, and what it rules out.

    "What is our approach?"
  3. 3Coherent actions

    A few pillars of concrete actions that reinforce each other.

    "How does each pillar help another?"

Revisit the diagnosis as evidence replaces assumptions.

Richard Rumelt's strategy kernel: diagnosis, guiding policy and coherent actions.

Use it when

  • Someone asks you for "the UX strategy" and your first draft is a list of goals ("be world-class", "improve consistency").
  • You finish a listening tour in your first 30 days and need to turn what you heard into a direction.
  • Your team does many good things, but nobody can say what they add up to.

How to use it

  1. Write the diagnosis. In 3–4 sentences, describe what is really going on: the critical challenge, not every problem. Mark each claim as evidence or assumption. Output: a short diagnosis with labelled claims.
  2. Write the guiding policy. In one sentence, state the overall approach to deal with the challenge, and what it rules out. Output: one guiding-policy sentence.
  3. Group your actions into pillars. Take your planned actions and group them into 3–5 themes. Each theme becomes a pillar of coherent actions. Output: 3–5 pillars, each with 2–4 concrete actions.
  4. Check coherence. For each pillar, name one way it helps another. If a pillar helps nothing else, question it. Output: a short list of "pillar A helps pillar B because…".
  5. Test it with your manager. Present the kernel, not a slide deck: "Here's the challenge, here's the approach, here are actions that reinforce each other. What am I missing?" Output: feedback and a revised kernel.

Worked example

The four-pillar example from the module. It is one example, not a template to copy: derive your own pillars from your own diagnosis.

Diagnosis (hypothesis)
UX in the internal applications grew domain by domain. Designers are isolated (often one per domain), practices and components drift, UX demand is invisible so it's allocated by urgency, and decisions rely mostly on opinion because usage data isn't systematic and is constrained by data protection.
Guiding policy
Build one connected UX practice that shares a common foundation and evidence, while leaving product decisions close to the domains.

Coherent actions (the pillars):

Pillar Actions
1. Consistent practice Shared principles, design-system governance, common process "minimum standard"
2. Growth & learning Cross-domain critique, mentoring pairs, career ladder, knowledge base
3. Transparent capacity Intake process, capacity map, prioritisation criteria agreed with stakeholders
4. Evidence-driven UX Maturity baseline, GDPR-safe metrics, lightweight benchmark of top tasks

The pillars reinforce each other: shared standards make cross-domain critique possible; capacity transparency frees time for research; evidence feeds the standards.

Watch out for

  • Goals posing as strategy. "Be world-class" is a wish, not a strategy. Start from a diagnosis of what is actually in the way.
  • A list of everything. If every activity the team does appears, nothing has been chosen. A guiding policy also says what you won't do.
  • A confident diagnosis built on guesses. Mark what is evidence and what is assumption. "My hypothesis is X; I'd confirm it by Y" is stronger than a plan built on guesses.
  • Copying someone else's pillars. Pillars come from your diagnosis. Another organisation may need three, five or completely different ones.

Template

Copy this into a one-page strategy draft.

Diagnosis (3-4 sentences, the critical challenge):
  1.                                   [evidence / assumption]
  2.                                   [evidence / assumption]
  3.                                   [evidence / assumption]

Guiding policy (one sentence: the approach, and what it rules out):

Coherent actions
  Pillar 1:            Actions:
  Pillar 2:            Actions:
  Pillar 3:            Actions:

Coherence check
  Pillar 1 helps Pillar __ because:
  Pillar 2 helps Pillar __ because:
  Pillar 3 helps Pillar __ because:
Source
Richard Rumelt

"See on Amazon" links are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Saved only on this device.

↑ ↓ to move · Enter to open · Esc to close