Framework · Facilitation techniques · 2 min read
What, So What, Now What
Facts → meaning → action: a debrief structure for research, pilots and retros.
- 1What?
Facts and observations only. What happened, what did we see and hear?
"What did you notice?" - 2So what?
Meaning: patterns, surprises and possible explanations.
"Why does this matter?" - 3Now what?
Action: what we do next, with owners and first steps.
"What do we do now?"
Each round: 1 min alone, 3–8 min in small groups, 2–3 min shared with everyone. About 20–40 minutes in total.
Use it when
- You debrief a round of research sessions with designers, product managers and developers.
- A pilot or experiment has ended and you need to decide what to do next.
- You run a retro and want to move from events to lessons to actions in a clear order.
How to use it
- Introduce the three questions. Show them on the board and explain that you will take them one at a time. Output: a shared structure. 2 minutes.
- What? Collect facts only. Each person writes what they saw, heard or measured (1 minute alone). Small groups of 5–7 share (3–8 minutes). A few people report key facts to everyone (2–3 minutes). Stay concrete: quotes, numbers, events. Output: a list of agreed facts.
- So what? Find the meaning. Same rhythm. Ask "Why does this matter? What patterns or surprises do we see?". Output: patterns and possible explanations.
- Now what? Decide the action. Same rhythm. Ask "What do we do next?" and finish with owners. Output: actions with owners and first steps. About 20–40 minutes in total.
Worked example
A UX lead debriefs a two-week pilot of a new order-entry screen with 2 designers, a product manager and 3 developers on an internal operations platform.
| Step | What the group wrote |
|---|---|
| What? | 12 planners used the screen. Average entry time went from 4 to 3 minutes. 5 planners asked where the save button was. Two planners went back to the old screen for rush orders. |
| So what? | The new screen is faster for normal orders. Save is hard to find. Rush orders may have a need we didn't design for. |
| Now what? | Designer moves save to a fixed footer (by next sprint). Researcher interviews the two planners about rush orders (this week). Product manager extends the pilot to one more site (after the fix). |
Watch out for
- Opinions at "What?". "The screen is confusing" is a meaning, not a fact. Ask "what did you see that made you think that?".
- Jumping to solutions. People want to fix things at "So what?". Park solution ideas until "Now what?".
- Ending without owners. Actions with no owner don't happen. Name an owner and a first step for each one.
- Skipping the silent minute. Without it, the first speaker frames the facts for everyone.
Template
Copy this into your debrief notes.
WHAT, SO WHAT, NOW WHAT Debrief of: ______________
Each round: 1 min alone · 3-8 min small groups · 2-3 min all
WHAT? What happened? What did we see, hear, measure?
(facts only: quotes, numbers, events)
SO WHAT? Why does it matter? What patterns or surprises?
NOW WHAT? What do we do next?
Action | Owner | First step | By when
Saved only on this device.