Marcus Andrey Study
Ler em português Library

Framework · Facilitation techniques · 2 min read

What, So What, Now What

Facts → meaning → action: a debrief structure for research, pilots and retros.

  1. 1What?

    Facts and observations only. What happened, what did we see and hear?

    "What did you notice?"
  2. 2So what?

    Meaning: patterns, surprises and possible explanations.

    "Why does this matter?"
  3. 3Now what?

    Action: what we do next, with owners and first steps.

    "What do we do now?"

Each round: 1 min alone, 3–8 min in small groups, 2–3 min shared with everyone. About 20–40 minutes in total.

What, So What, Now What moves a debrief from facts to meaning to action, one strict step at a time.

Use it when

  • You debrief a round of research sessions with designers, product managers and developers.
  • A pilot or experiment has ended and you need to decide what to do next.
  • You run a retro and want to move from events to lessons to actions in a clear order.

How to use it

  1. Introduce the three questions. Show them on the board and explain that you will take them one at a time. Output: a shared structure. 2 minutes.
  2. What? Collect facts only. Each person writes what they saw, heard or measured (1 minute alone). Small groups of 5–7 share (3–8 minutes). A few people report key facts to everyone (2–3 minutes). Stay concrete: quotes, numbers, events. Output: a list of agreed facts.
  3. So what? Find the meaning. Same rhythm. Ask "Why does this matter? What patterns or surprises do we see?". Output: patterns and possible explanations.
  4. Now what? Decide the action. Same rhythm. Ask "What do we do next?" and finish with owners. Output: actions with owners and first steps. About 20–40 minutes in total.

Worked example

A UX lead debriefs a two-week pilot of a new order-entry screen with 2 designers, a product manager and 3 developers on an internal operations platform.

Step What the group wrote
What? 12 planners used the screen. Average entry time went from 4 to 3 minutes. 5 planners asked where the save button was. Two planners went back to the old screen for rush orders.
So what? The new screen is faster for normal orders. Save is hard to find. Rush orders may have a need we didn't design for.
Now what? Designer moves save to a fixed footer (by next sprint). Researcher interviews the two planners about rush orders (this week). Product manager extends the pilot to one more site (after the fix).

Watch out for

  • Opinions at "What?". "The screen is confusing" is a meaning, not a fact. Ask "what did you see that made you think that?".
  • Jumping to solutions. People want to fix things at "So what?". Park solution ideas until "Now what?".
  • Ending without owners. Actions with no owner don't happen. Name an owner and a first step for each one.
  • Skipping the silent minute. Without it, the first speaker frames the facts for everyone.

Template

Copy this into your debrief notes.

WHAT, SO WHAT, NOW WHAT          Debrief of: ______________

Each round: 1 min alone · 3-8 min small groups · 2-3 min all

WHAT?      What happened? What did we see, hear, measure?
           (facts only: quotes, numbers, events)

SO WHAT?   Why does it matter? What patterns or surprises?

NOW WHAT?  What do we do next?
           Action | Owner | First step | By when
Source
Liberating Structures (Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless)
Saved only on this device.

↑ ↓ to move · Enter to open · Esc to close