Marcus Andrey Study
Ler em português Library

Framework · Facilitation techniques · 2 min read

Fist to Five

A quick consensus check: everyone shows 0–5 fingers for their level of support at the same time, and you discuss anything at 2 or below before you close the decision.

  1. 0 Fist
    Means
    I block this. We must not go ahead.
    Then
    Stop and hear the objection in full
  2. 1 finger
    Means
    Serious concerns. I need changes first.
    Then
    Ask what would make it a 3
  3. 2 fingers
    Means
    Some concerns I want to discuss.
    Then
    Ask what would make it a 3
  4. 3 fingers
    Means
    I can live with it and support it.
    Then
    Enough to go ahead
  5. 4 fingers
    Means
    I support it. It is a good idea.
    Then
    Enough to go ahead
  6. 5 fingers
    Means
    Full support. I will help lead it.
    Then
    Ask them to help with next steps

Discuss every 0, 1 or 2 before you close the decision.

Fist to Five turns a silent room into a visible level of support, from 0 (block) to 5 (full support).

Use it when

  • A discussion seems finished, but you are not sure whether silence means agreement.
  • You want to close a design-system or process decision in a mixed group of designers, developers and product managers.
  • A senior stakeholder is in the room and you want quieter people to show their real support level.

How to use it

  1. State the proposal in one sentence. Write it where everyone can see it, so people vote on the same thing. Output: one visible proposal.
  2. Explain the scale. 0 (a fist) means "I block this", 2 means "I have concerns I want to discuss", 3 means "I can live with it and support it", 5 means "full support, I will help lead it". Output: a shared meaning for each number.
  3. Count down and show at the same time. Say "3, 2, 1, show". Everyone shows their hand at once, so nobody copies the most senior person. On a call, people type the number in the chat and send on your signal. Output: a visible spread of support. Under 1 minute.
  4. Ask every low score what would make it a 3. Go to each 0, 1 or 2. Listen, don't defend the proposal. Output: the concrete concerns behind the low scores.
  5. Adjust and check again, or close. If the concerns lead to a change, update the proposal and run a second round. If everyone is at 3 or above, record the decision. Output: a decision with visible support, or a named open concern. About 5 minutes in total.

Worked example

A UX lead runs a design-system workshop with 6 designers and 2 frontend developers on an internal operations platform. After 40 minutes the group proposes: "All data tables use the shared filter panel from next quarter." The lead runs Fist to Five.

Round Result What the lead does
First show Five people show 4 or 5, two show 3, one developer shows 2 Asks the developer: "What would make it a 3 for you?"
Concern "Two old tables can't use the panel without a rebuild." The group adds: "Existing tables move when they are next rebuilt."
Second show Everyone shows 3 or above The lead records the decision and the exception in the workshop summary.

Watch out for

  • Votes that are not shown at the same time. If people raise hands one by one, they follow the first or most senior person. Always count down.
  • Treating it as a majority vote. Six fives do not cancel one fist. A 0 means there is a real objection you need to hear.
  • Rushing past the 2s. Saying "noted" and moving on teaches people that their concern does not matter. Ask the question and wait.
  • Using it too early. Fist to Five closes a decision. It does not replace the discussion, so run it after options are clear.

Template

Put this on the board or slide before you run the check.

FIST TO FIVE

Proposal: _________________________________________________

0  Fist   I block this. We must not go ahead.
1         Serious concerns. I need changes first.
2         Some concerns I want to discuss.
3         I can live with it and support it.
4         I support it. It is a good idea.
5         Full support. I will help lead it.

"3, 2, 1, show."
Everyone at 0-2: "What would make it a 3 for you?"

Result: ______   Changes made: ______   Decision recorded: yes / no
Saved only on this device.

↑ ↓ to move · Enter to open · Esc to close