Marcus Andrey Study
Ler em português Library

Motion and Interaction · For leads · 4 min read

Reviewing motion in critique

For leads: how to run a design critique on something that moves. What to ask people to bring, six lenses to look through, how to turn "it feels off" into a change someone can make, and how to see motion clearly enough to judge it.

"It feels a bit off" is the most common motion feedback, and the least useful. Motion is hard to critique because it's gone before you've looked at it, and because people react to it with their stomach before their head. A lead can change that: ask for the right material, look through the same few lenses every time, and give feedback in tokens and rules instead of feelings.

What you'll be able to do after reading:

  • Ask for motion work in a form people can critique
  • Review an animation through six lenses
  • Turn reactions into specific, actionable changes
  • Slow motion down to see what's really happening

1. Six lenses

LensThe questionNote on "basket drawer opens after Add"Verdict
PurposeWhat would people lose if it were cut?It shows where the item went. Worth keeping.Keep
TimingIs the duration a token from the scale?600 ms, typed by hand. The drawer is a large surface: motion.enter-large, 350 ms.Change
EasingDoes entering decelerate and leaving accelerate?Ease-in-out both ways. Enter curve to open, exit curve to close.Change
ChoreographyIs there one focal point at a time?The basket badge bounces while the drawer slides. Drop the bounce.Change
Reduced motionWhat happens with Reduce motion on?Not designed. Fade, 150 ms, like the other sheets.Add
PerformanceOnly transform and opacity? Seen on a slow phone?Animates width. Slide it with transform.Change
Six lenses for critiquing one animation, filled in for a real kind of case. Each note names the token or the rule, so the designer leaves with changes, not opinions about "feel".Rubric: Marcus Andrey, CC BY 4.0.

The figure is a critique of one common case: a basket drawer that opens when you add an item. Each lens is a question with a clear answer, and each note names the token or the rule. The designer leaves with five changes, not a vague sense that the team didn't like it.

The lenses come from the rest of this course:


2. What to ask people to bring

Motion can't be critiqued from a static frame. Before the session, ask for:

  • The job in one sentence. "This shows people where the item went." Critique the motion against the job, not against taste.
  • The real thing at real speed: a prototype, a build, or a screen recording, played more than once.
  • The same thing slowed down, so everyone sees the sequence.
  • The reduced-motion version, shown right after.
  • The tokens used, listed. Any raw value is a question.

Running critique well in general is covered in Design critique in practice. Motion adds one rule: watch it at least three times before anyone speaks.


3. See it slowly

At real speed, a 350 ms animation is over before you've decided what you think. Slow it down:

  • Chrome DevTools' Animations panel records the animations on a page and lets you replay them at a slower speed and inspect their source (Chrome for Developers, Inspect animations).
  • A screen recording, stepped frame by frame in any video player, shows overlaps and stutters.
  • Figma's prototype settings show the curve and the duration of each interaction.

Slowing down shows the problems that feel like "off": two things moving at once, an element that brakes instead of landing, a flicker at the end.


4. From reaction to change

When someone says "it feels slow" or "it feels cheap", translate it with them:

Reaction Usually means Ask
"Slow" Duration too long for how often it's used, or the wrong curve Which token? How many times a day will people see it?
"Floaty" An ease-in-out where it should decelerate, or a spring with too little damping Does it land, or drift to a stop?
"Busy" More than one focal point What should the eye follow?
"Jarring" No motion where there's a change of place, or a big slide Do people know where they are after it?
"Cheap" Bounces and overshoot on a productive task Is this an expressive moment?

The goal is that every note names something the designer can change: a token, a property, a direction, a sequence.


5. Separate rules from taste

Some feedback is a rule: tokens only, a reduced version, transform and opacity. Say so, and don't debate it. Some is taste: whether 250 or 350 ms suits a drawer. Say that too, and let the designer decide, or test it with people (see Usability testing with five people).

Val Head suggests motion principles exactly for this: they give teams an objective basis for judging animation instead of personal preference (Smashing Magazine, 2019).


6. Common mistakes

  • Critiquing from static frames or a single fast playback.
  • Starting with "do we like it?" instead of "what is it for?".
  • Feedback in adjectives: "snappier", "more fluid", "less janky".
  • Seeing the reduced-motion version for the first time after release.
  • The most senior person's taste deciding, with no principle behind it.

7. Try it (no tools needed)

  1. Pick an animation in an app you use often.
  2. Watch it five times. Write one line for each of the six lenses.
  3. Write one change, in tokens or properties, not adjectives.

Reflection questions: Which lens does your team skip most often? What would you need to bring to your next critique for motion to get a fair review?


Checklist

Learn more

Books, courses and videos to go deeper

Book links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Design critique in practice · Motion in design system governance · Motion, performance and budgets · Choreography and stagger · Motion principles for interfaces · Twelve principles of animation for UI

Saved only on this device.

↑ ↓ to move · Enter to open · Esc to close