Marcus Andrey Study
Ler em português Library

Motion and Interaction · Step 1 · 7 min read

What motion does in an interface

Motion is not decoration: it's how an interface shows a change instead of leaving people to spot the difference between two screens. The five jobs motion does, why the eye can't ignore it, and what the research says it improves.

A list, a detail panel and one card on its way between them, its path drawn as a dashed trail. Move the pointer from the list towards the panel and the card follows: it leaves its row, rises, grows and lands as the head of the panel. At rest it hangs halfway. That's this step in one gesture: motion earns its place when it shows where something went. This step has four lessons: what motion does in an interface, when not to animate, motion principles for interfaces, and auditing the motion in your product.Illustration: Marcus Andrey, drawn with Hairline (MIT, Lucas Marques).

An interface is a series of still pictures. Motion is what happens between them, and it decides whether people follow the change or lose it. Without motion, a screen jumps from one state to the next and leaves the person to work out what changed. With the right motion, the change explains itself: the panel came from the right, the badge went up by one, the fields belong to the box you ticked. That's the whole job. Everything else in this course is how to do it well.

What you'll be able to do after reading:

  • Name the five jobs motion does in an interface
  • Explain why motion grabs attention, for better and for worse
  • Point to the research on what animated transitions improve
  • Look at any animation and say which job it does, or that it does none

1. Motion shows a change

Tick to play, untick to play it back.
Feedback, 100 ms"Got it": the tick lands as you click
State change, 200 msThe menu icon becomes the close icon, so you see one became the other
Orientation, 300 ms inThe panel comes from the right, so that's where it goes back to
Relationship, 250 msThe new fields come out of the box you ticked: cause and effect
01AddAttention, 300 msA quiet number far from your eyes; one bump makes it seen
Five jobs motion does in an interface, each one a change someone needs to notice or understand. None of them is decoration. Live CSS: transition on transform and opacity, with the durations in the labels. With reduced motion on, the moves become instant or a short fade.

Tick the switch above and watch each tile. In every one, something changes state, and the motion shows how. Untick it and the same thing happens in reverse.

Interfaces used to be drawn as screens: one picture, then another. In 1993, Bay-Wei Chang and David Ungar put it plainly: static presentations are "a model ill suited for conveying change", so "events on the screen frequently startle and confuse users". Their answer came from cartoons: objects that arrive and depart smoothly instead of appearing out of nowhere, and transitions paced faster in the middle than at the ends (Chang and Ungar, UIST 1993). Thirty years later, that's still what good interface motion does.


2. The five jobs

Most useful motion in a product does one of five jobs. NN/g's review of motion in UX lists the same ones, with real examples (Page Laubheimer, The Role of Animation and Motion in UX, NN/g, 2020):

Job What it tells the person Example
Feedback "I got your action" A checkbox fills as you click; a button gives under the finger
State change "This became that" The menu icon turns into a close icon; a pencil becomes a save icon
Orientation "This is where you are, and where this lives" A panel slides in from the edge it closes back to; a photo zooms out to its month
Relationship "This came from that" New fields grow out of the option that asked for them
Attention "Look here, something changed" The cart badge bumps once when you add an item

Attention is the one to watch. NN/g's example is a cart badge that updates far from the Add button: people don't see the static change (change blindness), and may add the same product again. A small animation fixes it. The same power, used to push a countdown clock or a chat pop-up, becomes a distraction or a dark pattern.

There's a sixth thing motion always does, whether you plan it or not: it gives the product a character. Quick and precise feels like a tool; slow and bouncy feels like a toy. That's a real choice, but it comes after the five jobs, never instead of them.


3. Why the eye can't ignore it

Movement pulls attention before we decide to look. NN/g explains it with peripheral vision: we detect motion outside the centre of our view, and it's hard to stop attending to it (Aurora Harley, Animation for Attention and Comprehension, NN/g, 2014). Lab studies add a detail that matters for design: motion that looks self-propelled, as if the thing were alive, captures attention faster than motion that looks caused by a push (Pratt et al., Psychological Science, 2010).

Two consequences:

  • Motion is loud. Use it for the one thing that needs to be seen, and keep everything else still.
  • Cause and effect needs speed. For motion to read as the result of your action, it has to start within about 0.1 second of it (Harley, NN/g, 2014). Start later and it looks like the system did something on its own.

4. What the research says it improves

Motion isn't only a feeling. Two studies are worth knowing:

  • Spatial memory. Bederson and Boltman tested animated and instant viewpoint changes in a spatial interface. With animation, people were better at reconstructing the information space afterwards, "with no penalty on task performance time" (Bederson and Boltman, InfoVis 1999).
  • Reading changes in data. Heer and Robertson ran two experiments with charts that change from one form to another, and found that well-designed animated transitions "can significantly improve graphical perception" (Heer and Robertson, IEEE TVCG, 2007).

Both results come with a condition: the animation shows a change the person needs to follow. That's the line between motion that helps and motion that costs, and it's the next lesson.


5. Four ways to say why

When you defend an animation in a review, "it feels nice" won't hold. Issara Willenskomer's UX in Motion manifesto gives four words for how motion supports usability: expectation (it behaves as people expect), continuity (the flow doesn't break between states), narrative (events happen in an order that makes sense) and relationship (how objects are connected in space, time and hierarchy) (Willenskomer, Creating Usability with Motion, 2017). If you can't say which one your animation serves, it probably serves none.


6. Common mistakes

  • Adding motion at the end of a project, as polish, instead of designing it with the states.
  • Animating to "delight" when nothing is changing.
  • Moving something at the edge of the screen while people read.
  • An animation that starts a beat after the click, so it doesn't feel caused by it.
  • Several things moving at once, all asking for attention.

7. Vocabulary

Term Meaning
Motion Any change on screen over time: position, size, opacity, colour, shape
Transition Motion between two states of the interface
Feedback A response that shows the system received an action
Change blindness Missing a change on screen because nothing drew the eye to it
Animacy Motion that looks self-propelled, as if alive; it captures attention fast
Reduced motion A system setting that asks apps to cut non-essential motion

8. Try it (no tools needed)

  1. Open an app you use every day and do one task: send a message, add something to a basket, change a setting.
  2. Every time something moves, name its job: feedback, state change, orientation, relationship or attention.
  3. Count the moves you couldn't name.

Reflection questions: Which animation would you miss if it were gone? Which one did you only notice because you were looking for it?


9. If you already practise

  • Write the job next to every animation in your specs, in one word. It turns "I like it" debates into "does it do its job".
  • Design motion with the states, not after them: when you draw an empty state and a loaded one, also decide how one becomes the other.
  • Keep a short list of your product's motion moments; it's the start of the audit in Audit the motion in your product and of Motion tokens.

Checklist

Learn more

Books, courses and videos to go deeper

Book links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

When not to animate · Motion principles for interfaces · Affordances, signifiers and feedback · Interface states: empty, loading, error, success · How people think · Motion purpose check

Saved only on this device.

↑ ↓ to move · Enter to open · Esc to close