UX Foundations · Labs · 2 min read
Heuristic review of a real app
A guided lab: review three screens of an app you use against Nielsen's ten heuristics, write each problem with its location and a fix, rate its severity, and present the top three. About an hour, with paper or any notes app.
The quickest way to learn the heuristics is to use them on something real. In this lab you'll review an app you already use, as if you'd been hired to improve it. You'll be surprised how many small problems you've stopped noticing.
What you'll do:
- Pick an app and one task in it
- Review three screens against the ten heuristics
- Write, rate and rank what you find
- Present your top three, with a fix for each
You'll need: an app you use (on your phone or computer), paper or a notes app, about an hour.
1. Choose the app and the task
Pick something you use but didn't design: a banking app, a ticket machine, a food delivery app. Choose one task with at least three screens, for example "change the delivery address of an order". Write it at the top of your page.
2. Review each screen
For each screen, go through the ten heuristics from Heuristic evaluation one by one. Each time you spot a problem, write one line in a table like this:
| # | Screen | What's wrong | Heuristic | Severity (0-4) | Suggested fix |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Order details | The "Edit" link is grey and looks disabled | 1, Visibility of system status | 3 | Make "Edit address" a clear button near the address |
| 2 | Address form | Postcode error says only "Invalid" | 9, Help users recover from errors | 2 | Say what format is expected, with an example |
Tip: describe what you see, not your taste. "The button is grey and looks disabled" is a finding; "I don't like grey" is not.
3. Rate and rank
Give each problem a severity from 0 to 4 (see the scale in Heuristic evaluation). Sort the list: severity first, then how often people would hit it.
4. Present your top three
On one page, write your three most important problems. For each: a sketch or description of the screen, what's wrong, the heuristic, and your fix. That page is what a product team would actually read.
5. Check your work
Reflection questions: Which heuristic did you use most? Which problem do you think real users would hit first, and how could you check?
Optional, with others: ask two friends to review the same task alone, then merge your lists. How many problems did only one person find?
Related
Heuristic evaluation · Test with three people · How people think