Marcus Andrey Study
Ler em português Library

UX Research · Step 1 · 8 min read

Research ethics and consent

People lend you their time, their stories and sometimes their faces. The three principles behind research ethics, what informed consent really needs, a consent form you can adapt, and the special cases: colleagues, disabled participants, children and sensitive topics.

A participant is doing you a favour, and ethics is how you deserve it. Most UX research is low-risk: a video call, a prototype, a few questions. That's exactly why it's easy to get careless: recording without asking, sharing a clip in a team channel, quoting someone their manager can recognise. None of it feels harmful in the moment. All of it breaks the trust that makes people willing to help the next time.

What you'll be able to do after reading:

  • Explain the three principles of research ethics and what they mean in a design team
  • Get informed consent that's really informed, voluntary and recorded
  • Adapt a consent form and information sheet for your study
  • Handle the special cases: colleagues, disabled people, children, sensitive topics

1. What research ethics is

NN/g defines it as "the careful consideration of the rights, well-being, and dignity of people involved in research activities", and points out that it covers how you design a study, how you run it, and how you use the data afterwards (Rosala, Ethical Maturity in User Research, NN/g, 2019). It also notes that many people doing user research "have no formal research background", which is fine, as long as they learn the basics. This lesson is the basics.

Universities and hospitals have ethics committees that approve studies before they start. Most product teams don't. That doesn't lower the bar; it means the person running the study holds it.


2. Three principles

The Belmont Report, published in the US in 1979 after abuses in medical research, set out three principles that still underpin research ethics (The Belmont Report, 1979):

RespectPeople decide for themselves

They know what they're agreeing to, they can say no, and they can stop at any time without losing anything.

In UX: informed consent, no hidden observers, no tricks about the purpose
BeneficenceDo no harm, and weigh the rest

Keep risks small and worth what you'll learn. Stress, embarrassment and exposed data are harms too.

In UX: gentle tasks, care with sensitive topics, data kept safe
JusticeShare the burden and the benefit fairly

Don't study only the people who are easy to reach, and don't leave out the people the product will affect most.

In UX: who you recruit, who you exclude, fair pay for their time
The three principles of the Belmont Report, and what each one asks of a design team. Written in 1979 for medical and behavioural research, they still fit an interview on a video call.Diagram: Marcus Andrey, CC BY 4.0. Principles from The Belmont Report (1979).
  • Respect for persons: "individuals should be treated as autonomous agents", and people with diminished autonomy "are entitled to protection".
  • Beneficence: two rules, "(1) do not harm and (2) maximize possible benefits and minimize possible harms".
  • Justice: "Who ought to receive the benefits of research and bear its burdens?" In UX that's a recruiting question: who you include, who you leave out, and who keeps getting asked because they're easy to reach.

The UX profession has its own code. The UXPA Code of Professional Conduct lists seven principles, from "Act in the best interest of everyone" to "Respect privacy, confidentiality, and anonymity" and "Provide all resultant data", which includes reporting "both the positive and negative feedback" (UXPA Code of Professional Conduct). Honest reporting is an ethical duty, not only a quality one.


The Belmont Report says consent has three parts: information, comprehension and voluntariness (Belmont Report, Applications).

Information. The GOV.UK Service Manual lists what participants must understand: who is doing the research, its purpose, what data you collect, what will happen, how you'll use and share the results, that taking part is voluntary and they can stop or withdraw at any time, how long the data is kept, and their rights and how to complain. Also whether anyone is watching, and whether and how you record (GOV.UK, Getting informed consent for user research).

Comprehension. "The manner and context in which information is conveyed is as important as the information itself" (Belmont). Plain language, time to read, a chance to ask. GOV.UK recommends sending an information sheet before the session, so people aren't surprised.

Voluntariness. Consent must be "free of coercion and undue influence", and undue influence includes "an offer of an excessive, unwarranted, inappropriate or improper reward" (Belmont). The UXPA code says the same about incentives "likely to coerce participation". In practice: pay fairly, and pay at the start. GOV.UK recommends giving the incentive at the start of the session, which "avoids any suggestion that participants have to respond in a particular way to get their incentive" (GOV.UK, Finding participants).

NN/g puts the informal case bluntly: once you transcribe quotes from a "quick call" or share that person's information with your team, you're using their data "in a manner to which they did not agree" (Fessenden, Obtaining Consent for User Research, NN/g, 2022). If you'll keep anything, ask.


Taking part in a study about invoicing

Information sheet and consent · sent 3 days before
Who we are

Ana, a designer at Faturo. Faturo is responsible for your data. Questions or to stop at any time: research@faturo.example.

Names the data controller and a real way to reach them.
Why we're asking

We want to learn how freelancers bill their clients, so we can make the app easier. This is not a sales call, and nothing you say is a test of you.

The real purpose, in plain words.
What will happen

A 45-minute video call. We'll ask about the last time you sent an invoice. You can share your screen if you want to; you don't have to.

Who watches and what we record

Two colleagues may watch, cameras off. With your permission we record sound and screen. A transcription service turns the sound into text.

Observers, recording and every other organisation that touches the data.
What we keep, and for how long

Recordings and notes stay in one restricted folder and are deleted after 12 months. Reports use quotes without your name or company.

Thank you

A €40 voucher, sent at the start of the call. It's yours even if you stop after one minute.

Paid up front, so nobody feels they must please us to be paid.
Your choices
  • Taking part is voluntary. Skip any question, stop at any time.
  • Ask us to see or delete your data, even after the call.
  • You can complain to your data protection authority.
Consent
I agree to take partI agree to sound and screen recordingQuotes without my name may go in internal reports

Name · Date

One box per use, none ticked in advance. Saying no to recording still lets them take part.

A few choices in that example matter more than they look:

  • One box per use. Taking part, recording, and using quotes are separate. Someone can say yes to the interview and no to the recording.
  • Nothing pre-ticked, and no "by continuing you agree".
  • The data controller is named, with a real contact, so people know who to ask to stop or delete.
  • Every third party is listed, including transcription services and, if you use them, AI tools that process the recording.

Keep evidence of consent with the data it covers, named so you can match them (date, round, participant number). For remote sessions, GOV.UK says verbal consent on the recording is fine "as long as the participant has read the consent form you've sent them" (GOV.UK, Getting informed consent). The legal side, which depends on where you work, is in Research data and privacy.


Consent isn't a signature at minute one. GOV.UK asks you to remind people at the beginning and end of the session, and at any point "if you're not certain you have the participant's continued consent", for example if they seem uncomfortable. If someone withdraws, during or after the session, you stop and delete the data you collected (same source).

Say it in your own words at the start: "If you want to skip a question or stop, just say so. You keep the voucher either way." Then mean it.


6. Special cases

  • Colleagues. GOV.UK: you need consent from all participants, "even if they work for your organisation". With internal tools, be careful with quotes: stakeholders may recognise a colleague from a job title, so check what an anonymised quote really hides (Rosala, NN/g, 2019).
  • Disabled participants. Make the information sheet and form usable: read it aloud, offer a digital version for assistive technology, accept verbal consent if someone can't sign (GOV.UK). See also Inclusive design.
  • Children and vulnerable adults. Consent from the participant and from a parent, guardian or carer (same source). NN/g adds that some groups may not be able to give fully voluntary consent at all, and need extra precautions (Fessenden, NN/g, 2022).
  • Sensitive topics. Money trouble, health, grief. You can research them, with more preparation: warn people in advance, let them steer, and know what you'll do if someone gets upset. GOV.UK has a guide on researching emotionally sensitive subjects.

7. Common mistakes

  • Recording first and asking later, or asking with the recording already running.
  • One "I agree to everything" box.
  • Paying the incentive only if the session is "completed".
  • Sharing raw clips in a public team channel.
  • Quoting internal participants with details that identify them.
  • Treating a "quick chat" with a customer as exempt from consent.

8. Vocabulary

Term Meaning
Informed consent Agreement given with full information, understood, and free of pressure
Information sheet A plain-language document, sent before the session, that explains the study
Undue influence Pressure from an excessive or improper reward
Data controller The organisation responsible for the participants' data
Withdrawal A participant's right to stop and have their data deleted

9. Try it (no tools needed)

  1. Find the last consent form or invite your team used, or write the one you'd send today.
  2. Check it against the GOV.UK list in section 3. What's missing?
  3. Read it aloud. Could a participant explain, in their own words, what will happen to their recording?

Reflection questions: Have you ever shared a participant's clip or quote somewhere they didn't agree to? What would you need to change so it can't happen by accident?


10. If you already practise

  • Standardise the information sheet and consent form for your team, with blanks for each study. NN/g lists standard documents as a sign of an ethically mature practice (Rosala, 2019).
  • Run NN/g's ethics maturity questions with your team once a year.
  • Add AI tools to your consent form as soon as you use them to transcribe or summarise. See AI in UX research.

Checklist

Learn more

Book links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Research data and privacy · Recruiting participants · Inclusive design · Short user interviews · Ethics, bias and inclusion in AI design · AI in UX research

Saved only on this device.

↑ ↓ to move · Enter to open · Esc to close