Marcus Andrey Study
Ler em português Library

UX Research · Step 2 · 8 min read

Recruiting participants

The right six people beat the wrong sixty. Who to recruit, how to write a recruitment brief, where to find people and the bias each channel brings, how much to pay and when, and how to plan for the people who won't show up.

Recruiting is the unglamorous half of research, and it decides whether the other half is worth anything. A perfect interview guide with the wrong person gives you a perfect story about someone else's life. Jakob Nielsen called recruiting "the unglamorous foundation for all user testing" more than twenty years ago, and it's still where most studies go wrong: friends instead of customers, fans instead of people who left, whoever is free on Tuesday.

What you'll be able to do after reading:

  • Define who to recruit, in terms of behaviour, from the research questions
  • Write a recruitment brief an agency or a colleague can follow
  • Choose recruiting channels, knowing the bias each one brings
  • Set a fair incentive, pay it the right way, and plan for no-shows

1. Who you need

GOV.UK's rule is short: participants "must be actual or likely users of your service", and you should include "all the different kinds of people who may need your service", including disabled people, people with limited digital skills or literacy, and people who need help to use it (GOV.UK, Finding participants for user research).

Three steps get you from the plan to a profile:

  1. Start from the research questions. "How do freelancers bill a returning client?" needs freelancers who bill returning clients, and some who don't any more.
  2. Describe behaviour, not demographics. NN/g notes that demographic characteristics "are typically less important than behavioral characteristics" (Brown, Screening Participants, NN/g, 2024). "Invoiced the same client three months in a row" tells you more than "aged 30 to 45".
  3. Then add spread. Outside the specific criteria, GOV.UK recommends a spread of age, gender, ethnicity, disability and social and economic status.

Think about who you'd miss. Your own users won't include the people who tried you and left, or the ones who never signed up. Sometimes they're the most important people in the study.


2. Write a recruitment brief

A recruitment brief is the set of instructions that turns the plan into names on a calendar. GOV.UK says to always send an agency a written brief, even if they take instructions by phone, "in case there are problems with the recruitment" (GOV.UK, Write a recruitment brief). Write one even when you recruit yourself: it's what your screener is built from.

Recruitment brief · The second invoice

For the in-app invite and the agency backup · 4 March
Sessions

Remote video call, 45 minutes. 10 to 14 March, slots at 10:00 and 15:00 Lisbon time.

How many

6 people, plus 1 spare booked in case someone doesn't show.

No-shows happen in every study. One spare per five or six keeps the round whole.
Who, must have
  • Works as a freelancer or runs a business of one
  • 4 of 6: sent exactly one invoice with us in the last 90 days, none since
  • 2 of 6: sent an invoice with us in each of the last three months
Criteria are behaviour, not age or job title. They come straight from the research questions.
Spread

No more than 2 from the same trade. Welcome people who use assistive technology or have limited digital skills; we'll adapt the session.

Leave out

Our staff and their families, people who work in design or software, anyone we interviewed in the last 6 months.

Thank you

€40 voucher by e-mail at the start of the call. The agency handles payment for its recruits.

Data we need

First name, e-mail, chosen slot, screener answers. Deleted 30 days after the last session.

A filled-in recruitment brief: the instructions that turn a research plan into six real people on a calendar. Write it even when you recruit yourself. The study is invented.Diagram: Marcus Andrey, CC BY 4.0. Contents after GOV.UK Service Manual, Write a recruitment brief.

The brief covers dates and session length, location, how many people, the recruitment criteria and the incentive. GOV.UK adds one line every brief should have: make it clear you welcome disabled people and people with limited digital skills, because "recruiters often exclude these groups by default" (same source).


3. Where to find people

ChannelGood forWatch out for
Your own users (in-app invite, e-mail list, support tickets)Real customers, fast and cheap. People like helping a product they use.Permission to contact them. Only fans answer. You never meet people who left or never came.
A recruitment agencyThe general public, hard profiles, people who aren't your customers yet.Cost and lead time. Check their screener: agencies add their own questions and miss yours.
A research panel or platformSpeed, unmoderated tests, large numbers.Panels lean tech-savvy, and some members test for a living.
Communities, charities, professional bodiesSpecific groups, including disabled people, through someone they trust.Members can be more expert than typical users. Pay the organisation for its time too.
Intercepts and pop-up researchPeople in the place where the task happens: a library, a shop, a station.Short sessions. Ask permission to be there, and never pressure anyone.
ColleaguesInternal tools, where staff are the real users.For public products they know too much. Their results look better than reality.
Six ways to find participants, what each is good for, and the bias each one brings. Most studies mix two.Diagram: Marcus Andrey, CC BY 4.0. After GOV.UK Service Manual, Finding participants for user research, and Maddie Brown, Screening Participants for User-Research Studies (NN/g, 2024).

A few notes on the channels:

  • Your own users are the fastest source, but check that you have permission to contact them for research. GOV.UK's example: mention the research in a newsletter and let people register their interest (GOV.UK, Finding participants).
  • Panels and platforms are quick, but NN/g warns that people who volunteer for research panels include "many IT professionals and other individuals who are significantly more web-savvy than the average person", and that "professional testers" behave differently from the general population (Brown, NN/g, 2024).
  • Agencies send you a screener based on your brief. Always check it: GOV.UK says it's "not unusual for them to miss points you've included", and their standard questions may exclude people you want (GOV.UK, Write a recruitment brief).
  • Colleagues are the right participants for internal tools. For public products, GOV.UK advises against them: "their knowledge and experience can mean they will use the service in a very different way" (GOV.UK, Finding participants).

For B2B and enterprise products, recruiting usually goes through a gatekeeper: the account manager, the customer's admin, the person who signs the contract. Make them an ally early. Tell them what's in it for their team, and be clear that you'll never report what an individual employee said or did.


4. Incentives

GOV.UK: "It's normal for members of the public to get an incentive in return for their time." How much depends on the type of participant and the session length; agencies can advise (GOV.UK, Finding participants).

For a benchmark, User Interviews published recommendations based on "nearly 20,000" projects on its platform. For moderated studies with consumers, it recommends about $80 an hour for remote one-to-one interviews and $90 an hour in person; for professionals recruited for their job, the average for remote moderated studies was about $100 (User Interviews, The UX Research Incentives Report, updated January 2025). These are US-dollar figures from one platform's market. Use them as a starting point, adjust for your country, and treat the report as a vendor's data, not a standard.

Three rules matter more than the amount:

  • Pay at the start. GOV.UK recommends giving the incentive at the start of the session, so nobody feels they must answer a certain way to be paid, and so you can end a difficult session cleanly.
  • Cover extra costs. Disabled participants may need a helper, a taxi or an interpreter; GOV.UK says you may need to pay those expenses.
  • Fair, not excessive. The UXPA code asks practitioners to avoid inducements "likely to coerce participation" (UXPA Code of Professional Conduct). The ethics behind this are in Research ethics and consent.

Some organisations can't pay their own customers, or professionals can't accept payment. Then offer what you can: a donation to a charity they choose, early access, or simply a well-run session that respects their time. Say honestly in the invite what they'll get.


5. Plan for no-shows

Someone always cancels. In NN/g's 2003 survey of 201 usability professionals, the average no-show rate was 11%, "one in nine users" (Nielsen, Recruiting Test Participants for Usability Studies, NN/g, 2003). User Interviews' data shows no-shows falling as incentives rise: for in-person consumer studies, about 10% at $60 an hour and under 5% at $150 an hour (User Interviews, 2025).

In practice:

  • Book one spare for every five or six sessions, or a "floater" who's paid to be on standby.
  • Confirm the day before, with the time, the link and the name of the person they'll meet.
  • Make the first message easy to act on: one link, the session length, the incentive, and how to reschedule.

6. Common mistakes

  • Recruiting by demographics when behaviour is what matters.
  • Only recruiting fans, through a channel only fans answer.
  • Friends, family and colleagues for a public product.
  • Accepting an agency's screener without reading it.
  • Paying only "if the session is completed".
  • No spare participant, so one cancellation breaks the round.

7. Vocabulary

Term Meaning
Recruitment criteria The behaviours and traits that make someone right for the study
Recruitment brief Written instructions for recruiting: who, how many, when, where, incentive
Incentive What participants receive for their time
No-show A confirmed participant who doesn't turn up
Floater A spare participant paid to be on standby
Gatekeeper The person who controls access to participants, common in B2B

8. Try it (no tools needed)

  1. Take the participants line from your research plan.
  2. Rewrite every criterion as a behaviour with a time frame: "sent an invoice in the last 90 days", not "uses invoicing".
  3. Pick two channels from the table, and write the bias each would bring to your study.

Reflection questions: Whose experience would your usual channel never reach? What would it take to reach them this time?


9. If you already practise

  • Build a research panel of your own users who've opted in, with consent to contact and a record of when each was last invited. Kate Towsey's Research That Scales covers how to build participant recruitment systems.
  • Track no-shows and time-to-recruit per channel. After a few studies, you'll know your real lead times.
  • Agree an incentive table with finance once, so you don't negotiate it for every study.

Checklist

Learn more

Books, courses and videos to go deeper

Book links go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Writing a research plan · Screeners and sampling · Research ethics and consent · Inclusive design · Usability testing with five people · ResearchOps · Screener questionnaire

Saved only on this device.

↑ ↓ to move · Enter to open · Esc to close