Marcus Andrey Study
Ler em português Library

AI for UX · Step 3 · 6 min read

Copyright and AI-generated assets

What designers need to know in late 2026 about owning and using AI-generated work: when output can be protected, what recent court cases decided, what the EU requires of model makers, which vendors offer legal protection, and how to keep a safe record of your own creative contribution.

Two questions sit behind every AI-generated asset. Can anyone own it, including you or your client? And could using it infringe someone else's rights? The answers depend on how much of the work is yours, which tool you used, and where you are. This note gives you the map.

What you'll be able to do after reading:

  • Explain when AI-assisted work can be protected by copyright, and when it can't
  • Summarise the court cases and rules designers hear about most
  • Check whether a tool's terms, and any legal protection it offers, cover your use
  • Keep a simple record of your human contribution for work that matters

1. Can AI output be owned?

In the US, the Copyright Office's January 2025 report is the clearest guidance. AI output is protected only "where a human author has determined sufficient expressive elements"; prompts alone are not enough. What can be protected: your own expressive input that stays visible in the result, and your creative selection, arrangement or modification of AI material (US Copyright Office).

The courts agree. In Thaler v. Perlmutter, the US appeals court ruled that copyright requires a human author, and in March 2026 the Supreme Court declined to hear the case, so that ruling stands (Supreme Court docket 25-449).

  1. 1Prompt only

    You typed a request; the machine made every expressive choice.

    Not protected (US)
  2. 2Your input visible

    Your own sketch, photo or text stays recognisable in the result.

    Your part can be protected
  3. 3Selected and arranged

    You chose, combined and ordered AI pieces creatively.

    The arrangement can be protected
  4. 4Substantially modified

    You reworked the AI output with your own expressive changes.

    Your changes can be protected
How much of an AI-assisted work can be owned, following the US Copyright Office (Jan 2025). Other countries differ. Diagram: Marcus Andrey, CC BY 4.0.
The first printed page of the Statute of Anne, 1710:
The Statute of Anne (1710), often called the first copyright law, gave rights to authors, not to printers. The question AI raises is the same one: who counts as the author? Image: British Government, Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Other countries take their own positions; if ownership matters (a logo, a brand mascot, a book cover), ask a lawyer where you'll use it.


2. Could using it infringe someone else's rights?

This is about how models were trained and what they output.

Case or rule What it decided What it means for you
Bartz v. Anthropic (US) A US$1.5 billion settlement, about US$3,000 per book, for books obtained from pirate libraries; final approval July 2026 (settlement site) How training data was obtained matters, and it can be expensive
Getty Images v. Stability AI (UK, Nov 2025) The main copyright claim failed: a model that doesn't store or reproduce the works isn't an "infringing copy". Getty won only a narrow trade-mark point about generated watermarks (judgment) Outputs that reproduce marks or recognisable works are where the risk is
US Copyright Office, training report (May 2025) Analysis of when training may or may not be fair use; still a pre-publication version (USCO AI) The question is not settled in the US
EU: AI Act and the Code of Practice Since 2 Aug 2025, makers of general-purpose AI models must have a copyright policy, respect machine-readable opt-outs and publish a summary of their training content (Commission Q&A; Code of Practice) Obligations fall on model makers, not on you as a user
EU text-and-data-mining opt-out Commercial mining is allowed unless the rightholder reserved it, for example in machine-readable form (DSM Directive, Art. 4) Publishers can opt their content out of AI training

The practical risk for a designer is rarely the training debate; it's output that looks too much like something specific: a recognisable character, a living artist's signature style, a brand's logo, a real person's face.


Several vendors promise to defend business customers if their AI output is accused of infringing copyright. All have conditions, and none covers free or personal plans:

MicrosoftCustomer Copyright Commitment

Commercial Copilot and Azure OpenAI, if you use the built-in guardrails.

Since Sep 2023
GoogleGenerative AI indemnification

Listed Google Cloud and Workspace services: training data and output.

Since Oct 2023
OpenAIService terms

API and business plans; not if you knew it infringed or disabled safety features.

Beta features excluded
AdobeFirefly

Listed features, for customers whose agreement includes it.

Mostly enterprise
Vendor promises to defend business customers against copyright claims over AI output, as of Nov 2026. None covers free or personal plans; read the conditions. Diagram: Marcus Andrey, CC BY 4.0.

Read the conditions: most require using the tool's built-in safety filters, and none protects you if you knew, or should have known, that the output infringed. Partner models inside a tool may not be covered (see AI for visual design: images and video).


4. Faces, voices and likeness

  • In the EU, realistic AI images, audio or video of real people, places or events (deepfakes) must be labelled as AI-generated since 2 August 2026 (AI Act, Article 50), and AI that generates non-consensual intimate imagery is banned from 2 December 2026.
  • In the US, there is no federal law on digital replicas yet; the Copyright Office recommended one in 2024 (USCO AI). Many states have their own rules.
  • Everywhere: don't generate real, identifiable people (customers, colleagues, celebrities) without their consent, and don't present generated people as real customers or testimonials.

5. A record of your contribution

For assets whose ownership matters, keep a short record. It costs minutes and can matter later:

  • The tool, model and plan you used, and the date
  • Your prompts and reference images, and where the references came from
  • What you selected, changed and combined: sketches, edits, layers, final choices
  • The licence terms of the tool at that date (save a copy)

6. Vocabulary

Term Meaning
Copyright The right to control copies of an original creative work
Fair use / exceptions Legal room to use protected works without permission in some cases
Indemnity A vendor's promise to defend you, and pay, if a covered claim arises
Text and data mining Automated analysis of large amounts of content, including for AI training
Likeness A person's recognisable face, voice or identity
Trade mark A protected sign (a name, logo) that identifies a brand

7. Try it (no code needed)

  1. Pick one AI-generated asset you've used (an illustration, an icon set, a hero image).
  2. Find the tool's current terms: who owns the output? May you use it commercially? Is there an indemnity on your plan?
  3. Write a four-line record for it (section 5).
  4. Decide: is this an asset where ownership matters? If yes, what would you change about how you make the next one?

Reflection questions: Which of your deliverables would you never generate with AI, and why? Who in your organisation should see the indemnity conditions?


8. If you lead a team

  • Keep the approved tools list with each tool's ownership terms and indemnity status.
  • Agree which assets must not be AI-generated (logos, brand mascots, anything with real people) and which need a record.
  • Ask legal to review the indemnity conditions before relying on them.

Checklist

Learn more

AI for visual design: images and video · AI governance and data protection · Ethics, bias and inclusion in AI design · AI tools landscape for designers

Saved only on this device.

↑ ↓ to move · Enter to open · Esc to close