Module 1 of 12 · 11 min read
Self-Assessment: Where You Are Today
A scored baseline of your leadership skills across eight competency areas, checked against other people's view, so you know where to grow first.
"You can't plan a route without knowing where you're standing."
Why it matters
Most new leads have a vague sense of their gaps: "I'm not great at difficult conversations", "I should speak up more". Vague gaps are hard to work on and impossible to measure. This module turns them into a scored baseline so you can:
- talk about your strengths and gaps precisely with your manager, your team, and in any leadership conversation;
- choose where to invest first, instead of trying to improve everything at once;
- measure your progress at month 6 and month 12.
Common pitfalls
- Scoring from feeling, not evidence. A score without an example is a guess. Every score needs a "when did I last do this?"
- Only self-scoring. Your view of yourself has blind spots. The "Others" column is where most of the learning happens.
- Being too modest or too generous. Many people score their strongest craft skills too low and their people skills too high (or the reverse). Evidence corrects both.
- Trying to fix everything. Pick three areas. The rest can wait.
1. UX Lead competency matrix
How to score
Score yourself 1–5 on each competency. Then ask 2–4 people who see you work (your manager, a peer designer, a product manager, an engineering lead) to score you on the same items, or on the areas they can observe.
| Level | Meaning | Typical evidence |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Aware: I know this exists | I've read about it or seen others do it |
| 2 | Learning: I've tried it with support | One or two attempts, with help or feedback |
| 3 | Practising: I do it reliably in my own scope | Repeated examples in my own team or product |
| 4 | Leading: I do it across teams, and others come to me for it | People ask for my help; I've taught it or set it up for others |
| 5 | Shaping: I set the standard for the organisation | My approach is the documented default others follow |
Target for a newly appointed UX lead: mostly 3s, some 4s, and a clear plan for the 2s. Very few people have 5s in more than one or two areas, and that is fine.
Rules for honest scoring
- Evidence first, number second. Write the example in the Evidence column, then choose the score.
- Use the last 12 months. What you did five years ago, in a different role, counts less.
- When in doubt, score lower and note why. You can raise it when the evidence arrives.
- "Others" is an average or a range (e.g. "2–3"). Note big gaps between Self and Others; they are the most useful data in the whole matrix.
A. Craft & quality bar
| # | Competency | Self | Others | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | Interaction & visual design quality for complex applications | |||
| A2 | Research planning & synthesis (qualitative) | |||
| A3 | Design systems: components, tokens, documentation | |||
| A4 | Giving design critique that raises quality without taking over | |||
| A5 | Defining and communicating a quality bar / design principles |
Evidence prompts: Which recent piece of work best shows your quality bar? When did your critique change someone else's design for the better, and did they keep ownership of it? Could a new designer find your principles written down?
B. People leadership
Deep dive: Module 4: People Leadership
| # | Competency | Self | Others | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| B1 | Running effective 1:1s | |||
| B2 | Giving clear, kind, specific feedback (positive and corrective) | |||
| B3 | Coaching: asking rather than telling | |||
| B4 | Delegating outcomes, not tasks | |||
| B5 | Supporting career growth (ladders, development plans) | |||
| B6 | Handling underperformance / difficult conversations | |||
| B7 | Building psychological safety in a distributed team | |||
| B8 | Hiring & onboarding designers |
Evidence prompts: When did you last give corrective feedback, and what changed afterwards? Name one person who grew because of something you did. What did you delegate last month, and did you take it back? Have you ever had a conversation you were dreading, and how did it go?
C. Strategy & vision
Deep dive: Module 6: UX Strategy & Vision
| # | Competency | Self | Others | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | Articulating a UX vision others can repeat | |||
| C2 | Connecting UX work to business / operational goals | |||
| C3 | Building a UX roadmap / multi-quarter plan | |||
| C4 | Prioritising with explicit criteria |
Evidence prompts: Could someone outside UX explain your vision in one sentence? Which business goal did your last project move, and can you show it? When you last said "this first, that later", what criteria did you use, and were they written down?
D. Operations (DesignOps)
Deep dive: Module 7: DesignOps, Team Models & Capacity
| # | Competency | Self | Others | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| D1 | Capacity planning & resource allocation across teams | |||
| D2 | Designing team rituals (critique, sharing, syncs) | |||
| D3 | Standardising process without bureaucracy | |||
| D4 | Tooling & workflow improvement | |||
| D5 | Design-system governance & contribution models |
Evidence prompts: Do you know, today, what every designer near you is working on and how full their week is? Which ritual have you started, and is it still running without you pushing it? Which tool or workflow change have you led, and how many people adopted it?
E. Influence & stakeholders
Deep dive: Module 10: Stakeholders, Influence & Change
| # | Competency | Self | Others | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| E1 | Mapping and managing stakeholders | |||
| E2 | Influencing without authority | |||
| E3 | Saying no / negotiating scope | |||
| E4 | Communicating with senior management (concise, outcome-focused) | |||
| E5 | Leading change & adoption | |||
| E6 | Facilitating workshops & alignment sessions |
Evidence prompts: Who are the five people whose support your work depends on, and when did you last talk to each? When did you change a decision you didn't own? When did you last say "no" or "not yet" to a request, and how was it received? Which workshop did you run, and what decision came out of it?
F. Measurement & evidence
Deep dive: Module 9: UX Maturity & Measurement
| # | Competency | Self | Others | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| F1 | Choosing UX metrics tied to goals (HEART, task metrics) | |||
| F2 | Using analytics responsibly under GDPR / data constraints | |||
| F3 | Assessing and evolving UX maturity | |||
| F4 | Telling a story with qual + quant evidence |
Evidence prompts: Which UX metric do you track today, and who looks at it? Have you ever used data to change a stakeholder's mind? Could you describe your organisation's UX maturity level and what the next step would be?
G. Personal leadership
Deep dive: Module 3: Personal Leadership Presence
| # | Competency | Self | Others | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| G1 | Proactivity: raising issues early, proposing before asked | |||
| G2 | Voice & presence in cross-team / senior meetings | |||
| G3 | Healthy disagreement ("disagree and commit") | |||
| G4 | Written communication (memos, proposals, decisions) | |||
| G5 | Self-management: focus, energy, boundaries |
Evidence prompts: What did you propose last month that nobody asked for? In your last cross-team meeting, did you speak, and did it change anything? When did you last disagree openly, and with whom? What have you written that people still refer to?
H. AI-era leadership
Deep dive: Module 12: AI and the UX Lead
| # | Competency | Self | Others | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| H1 | Using AI tools well in my own design work (specs, prototypes, research) | |||
| H2 | Writing AI-ready specs and context files (Design specs for AI) | |||
| H3 | Reviewing AI-generated work against principles, design system and accessibility (AI design review process) | |||
| H4 | Guiding others through AI adoption (Guiding designers through AI adoption) | |||
| H5 | AI governance: data protection, approved tools, EU AI Act basics (AI governance and data protection) | |||
| H6 | Designing AI features & agents for users (Agentic design) |
Evidence prompts: For which tasks do you use AI every week, and for which never? Have you caught a problem in AI-generated work that others missed? Do you know which tools your organisation allows, and with which data?
2. Reading your profile
Once the matrix is filled in, step back and look for the pattern. Don't look only at single scores.
Step 1 — Average each area
Write the average Self score and average Others score for each area A–H. This gives you eight numbers instead of 43.
| Area | Self avg | Others avg | Gap (Others − Self) |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. Craft & quality bar | |||
| B. People leadership | |||
| C. Strategy & vision | |||
| D. Operations | |||
| E. Influence & stakeholders | |||
| F. Measurement & evidence | |||
| G. Personal leadership | |||
| H. AI-era leadership |
Step 2 — Find your lowest areas and your biggest gaps
- Lowest two areas: your most likely development areas.
- Positive gap (others score you higher): an area you undervalue. Often a strength you can use more openly.
- Negative gap (others score you lower): a blind spot. Take it seriously, and ask for a concrete example.
Step 3 — Name your profile in one line
Write one sentence that sums up your profile, e.g. "strong in X and Y, developing in Z."
A very common profile for a first-time lead coming from a senior design role is: strong in craft, systems and practice; developing in people and power (areas B, E and G). If that is you, it is normal, and it is a credible story when you say it plainly. Other common profiles:
| Profile | Typical pattern | First focus |
|---|---|---|
| The craft expert | High A and D, low B and E | Delegation, feedback, stakeholder mapping |
| The connector | High E and B, lower A and F | Raise and document a quality bar; learn metrics |
| The strategist | High C and F, lower B and D | 1:1s, team rituals, capacity visibility |
| The quiet expert | High A and G4 (writing), low G1–G3 | Proactivity, speaking up, healthy disagreement |
These are prompts for reflection, not boxes. Use them to sharpen your own sentence.
Step 4 — Choose three development areas
For each, write:
Development area: ___ (competency codes, e.g. B2, B6)
Evidence it's a gap: ___ (scores + one real example)
Concrete action in the next 90 days: ___
How I'll know it improved: ___ (observable, e.g. "gave 3 corrective SBI feedbacks, logged")
Who can help: ___
3. 360° feedback mini-survey
Send this to 4–6 people: designers, product managers, developers, your manager. Keep it short; people answer short surveys.
- What is one thing I do that makes your work easier?
- When have you seen me have the most impact beyond my own tasks?
- What is one thing I should start doing to be a stronger leader?
- What is one thing I should stop or do less of?
- In meetings with several teams, how would you describe my presence? (quiet / balanced / dominant, plus a comment)
- If I were leading UX across several teams, what would you most want from me?
How to ask:
"I'm working on my development as a UX leader and would value your honest perspective. It's 6 short questions, 10 minutes max. Anything critical is especially useful."
Tips
- Offer an anonymous option (a simple form) for people who will be more honest that way.
- Thank everyone, and tell them one thing you'll do with their input. It makes the next round easier.
- Look for themes that appear two or more times, not single comments.
Asking for feedback is itself a leadership behaviour. People notice it, and it gives them permission to ask for feedback too.
4. Leadership style reflection
Answer in writing (½ page each):
- Best leader I've worked with. What did they do that made me better?
- Worst leadership moment I've witnessed. What would I have done differently?
- When do I avoid speaking up, and what's the cost? Be specific: which meetings, which people.
- What do I need to let go of to spend more time on people and direction? (e.g. pixel-level control, being the expert on every component)
- What kind of team do I want to build? Three adjectives, then describe a normal Tuesday in that team.
5. Output
Evidence to collect
Keep proof in your Leadership log:
- The first completed matrix (dated), so you can compare later.
- The themes from the 360° survey, and the one change you made because of it.
- The three development areas with their actions.
Talking about it
Your self-assessment is useful far beyond your own notebook.
- With your manager: share your one-line profile and your three development areas. Ask: "Does this match what you see? What would you add?" It turns a vague "keep growing" into a shared plan, and gives your manager a way to support you.
- With your team: being open about one thing you're working on ("I'm practising giving clearer corrective feedback, so tell me if I'm vague") models the learning culture you want.
- In a promotion or hiring conversation: when asked about your development areas, answer with the pattern: the gap → the evidence → what I'm doing about it → early results. For example: "My formal people-management experience is limited. I've been running regular mentoring 1:1s, I ran a 360° survey, and the main theme was that I should give corrective feedback sooner. I've started using SBI and log every piece of feedback I give." Honest, specific and in progress beats a polished non-answer.
Check yourself
Answer out loud, then open the section to compare.
- Which two areas score lowest, and what's your evidence? → answer
- Who gets your 360° survey, and which question matters most to you? → answer
- How will you know in three months that you've moved? → answer
Connections
← Course start · Learning path · Module 2: The Role Shift →
Related
- Module 2: The Role Shift: what the lead role actually looks like
- 12-Month Learning Plan: carry your top-3 development areas into the plan
- Module 3: Personal Leadership Presence: presence & confidence (area G)
- Module 4: People Leadership: people-leadership competencies (area B)
Hubs: Frameworks index